Tag: Judicial Panel

  • LASG, LCC ask judicial panel to strike out #EndSARS protest coordinator’s testimony

    LASG, LCC ask judicial panel to strike out #EndSARS protest coordinator’s testimony

    One of the Coordinators of the #EndSARS protests, Serah Ibrahim again failed to show up for her cross-examination on Saturday at the Lagos State judicial panel on restitution for victims of SARS-related abuses and other matters.

    This prompted the lawyers representing the Lagos State Government, the Lekki Concession Company, LCC and the Police to ask the panel to strike out her previous testimony.

    They premised their application on her continued absence at the proceedings of the panel.

    During her previous testimony, Serah, who described herself as a professional auditor said she was at the protest ground every day and in fact helped in coordinating activities.

    Led by her lawyer, Yinka Olumide-Fusika (SAN), Serah had narrated how the Nigerian Army and subsequently the police shot at protesters at the Lekki toll gate on the night of October 20, 2020.

    She testified that at least 10 persons were killed.

    During her appearance at the panel on May 8, Serah came along with several videos, some of which she said she shot personally with her iPhone.

    One after the other, she played the videos which according to her demonstrates that soldiers shot at peaceful protesters on the night of October 20.

    As she played the videos, she explained to the panel that soldiers shot at the harmless protesters and even took away some of the dead bodies.

    Counsel to the Lagos State Government, Olukayode Enitan (SAN), in his application to strike out her testimony told the panel that the witness has been evading cross-examination after making “scandalous and outrageous claims.”

    He asked the panel to note that this is about the 4th court sitting that the witness had failed to turn up for and having failed to present herself for cross-examination, she should be deemed to have abandoned the cause.

    The Senior Advocate’s application was supported by Counsel to the LLC, Rotimi Seriki and Counsel to the Police, Joseph Eboseremen.

    On her part, the Chairman of the Panel, Justice Doris Okuwobi said members would consider the application and take a decision which would be communicated later.

    She adjourned the proceedings till September 11.

  • Lagos #EndSARS judicial panel gets another tenure extension

    Lagos #EndSARS judicial panel gets another tenure extension

    The tenure of the Lagos State Judicial Panel on Restitution for Victims of SARS Related Abuses and other matters has again been extended for another three months.

    The Chairman of the panel, Justice Doris Okuwobi stated this while hearing petitions on Friday.

    This means that the panel will now sit until October 19, a day before the October 20, 2020 shootings at the Lekki toll gate.

    Recall that the Lagos State judicial panel was inaugurated by Governor Babajide Sanwo-Olu of Lagos State on October 27, 2020.

    The panel was set up to last for a period of six-month in response to the government acceding to the five-for-five demands of the #EndSARS protesters with a mandate to look into abuses by security agencies and the now-disbanded SARS unit of the Nigeria police force and to make recommendations to the authorities for restitution to victims of abuses.

    The initial six months sitting of the Lagos panel expired on April 27, 2021, and the panel was granted a three-month tenure extension which is supposed to expire on Monday, July 19 but as of June 29, the panel had sat for 97 days and only heard 126 petitions out of the 235 petitions it received.

    Since the commencement of the hearing, 37 had been concluded while 109 petitions remained unheard necessitating the request for an extension of time.

    At Friday’s sitting, the panel heard eleven petitions. It reserved its decision in six petitions after counsel in the matters adopted their final written addresses.

  • EndSARS protest opened our eyes – Gov Okowa

    EndSARS protest opened our eyes – Gov Okowa

    Delta State Governor Ifeanyi Okowa has said the EndSARS protest embarked on by Nigerians youths in 2020 to end police brutality opened the eyes of leaders to the suffering Nigerians pass through.

    TheNewsGuru.com (TNG) reports Governor Okowa stated this on Friday while receiving the report of the State’s Judicial Panel of Inquiry into complaints of police brutality and extra-judicial killings in the State, at Government House, Asaba.

    Okowa said the EndSARS protest opened a new chapter in the history of the country, and pointed out that no amount of monetary compensation would bring back lost lives.

    While advising the Police to always be cautious when dealing with human lives, the Governor said the State Government would do its best to support families of victims of police brutality and extra-judicial killings in the State.

    The Governor said that his administration would consider and implement the decisions of the panel and urged the police to see the civil populace as partner in intelligence-gathering rather than antagonists.

    He assured that the recommendations would be looked into by the State’s Executive Council, and that justice would be done as much as possible.

    “We are all very much aware of the impact of ENDSARS in our country. It opened a new chapter in the history of our country, where it became very obvious that many of our citizens across the nation were suffering silently.

    “Many of them were in real pains, rising from loss of loved ones or loved ones that have been maimed by the Police.

    “Rising from several stakeholders meetings, we decided that all states should constitute judicial panels of enquiry, for which Delta state constituted one,” the Governor said.

    He thanked the Chairman of the panel and members for their painstaking effort in the discharge of the assignment, adding that he was glad that Deltans came out to lay their complaints before the committee.

    “I want to reassure you that the recommendations made will be looked into very urgently by the state executive council and that justice will be done to the best that we can as human beings.

    “We can not bring the dead to live and no amount of money can buy a soul. However, we will do the best we can to sympathise with the families and victims.

    “The fact that we have accepted that something went wrong could help the families heal and we need to lend a helping hand to them. I do pray that we continue as a people to stay very civil.

    “A lot of Police officers do their work the way it ought to be done. But it’s unfortunate that some few take laws into their hands and treat people they were supposed to protect as if they ought not to exist.

    “That’s not supposed to be so; human lives can only be created by God. So, as much as possible, it is necessary to give respect to that life which we cannot create.

    “I was waiting to see the report and know the extent to which our people have really suffered in the hands of security agencies before setting up the human rights complaints team.

    “Whatever is being done is not to scrap the Police because we believe that many of them are doing there jobs. In fact, we have to find way to strengthen and encourage them,” he stated.

    The Governor added that it was not unknown that in Nigeria, many policemen work in difficult circumstances, sometimes without equipment to be able to effectively do their jobs.

    He, however, said that such situation did not give room for people to abuse their offices.

    “Therefore, we advise the security agencies which tend to give a bad name to the Police Force and other agencies to desist from doing that.

    “I believe that when the police work with the civil class, it will help them in information gathering.

    “So, we look forward to a good working relationship of both the government and the police itself in order to provide better policing of our nation without having to go the path that will make our people distrust us,” the governor stated.

    Earlier, Chairman of the Judicial Panel of Inquiry, Justice Celestina Ogisi (Retd), had presented the panel’s report and thanked the governor for finding the members worthy to serve.

    She recalled that the Panel was inaugurated on October 9, 2020, to receive and inquire into complaints of police brutality and extra-judicial killings in the state, evaluate evidence presented and draw conclusions as to the validity of the complaint(s), and recommend compensation and other remedial measures.

    According to her, the Panel commenced work immediately after inauguration by calling for memoranda from interested members of the public and held public sitting at Asaba and Warri.

    “In total, the Panel received 86 petitions and 49 were heard on merit while 37 were struck out for various reasons.

    “The Panel also received 10 petitions which sought the enforcement of judgments of various High Courts of the State against the Police for acts of Police brutality and extra-judicial killings.

    “The Panel recommended the payment of compensation to victims and/or their families for various acts of Police brutality and extra-judicial killings in Delta State.

    “We also recommended the enforcement of all judgment debts awarded against the Police, which they have refused to obey till date,” Justice Ogisi stated.

    She added that the Police were meant to protect rights of citizens and not routinely breach such rights without being held accountable.

    “Police should restrict itself to the performance of their constitutional and statutory duties of preserving life and properties and not go outside the ambit of the law,” she added.

  • BREAKING: Lagos judicial panel issues compensation to victims of Police brutality

    BREAKING: Lagos judicial panel issues compensation to victims of Police brutality

    The Lagos State judicial panel hearing cases of police brutality on Friday, awarded compensation to some victims of police brutality the panel has heard their cases and found meritorious.

    In a petition involving late Mrs. Kudirat Adebayo Abayomi, the panel on Friday, recommended the prosecution of the erring police officers, N10 million to be awarded as compensation to the family of the deceased, a scholarship, and a letter of apology to the family of the deceased from the police.

    The second petitioner, Hannah Olugbode, was awarded the sum of N10 million for the stress and anxiety she suffered, and to help her undergo treatment.

    Justice Doris Okuwobi (retrd) in her recommendation also noted that erring officers who have commited these abuses are sanctioned.

     

  • IGP Adamu disowns suit against judicial panels, queries police legal officer

    IGP Adamu disowns suit against judicial panels, queries police legal officer

    The Nigerian Police have dissociated themselves from a suit challenging the legality of judicial panels of inquiry set up by state governors to probe the atrocities of the disbanded Special Armed Robbery Squad (SARS).

    According to a statement by Police spokesman, DCP Frank Mba, the Inspector General of Police, Mohammed Adamu, has directed immediate investigations into the suit.

    Even though the suit was not inspired by Adamu’s office, the police statement indicated that it came from the Legal Department.

    Mba said the Force Legal Officer has been queried and may face further sanctions if found guilty of dereliction of duty.

    Mba said Adamu has expressed the disapproval of the Force Management Team on the matter and ordered investigations into the alleged role of the Force Legal Section including its Head.

    “The IGP reiterates the commitment of the Force to fulfilling all its obligations with regards to the disbandment of the defunct SARS, the ongoing Judicial Panels and all other police reforms”, Mba said.

  • Get me back on my feet, Poly student who lost leg to #EndSARS protest tells Judicial Panel of Inquiry

    Get me back on my feet, Poly student who lost leg to #EndSARS protest tells Judicial Panel of Inquiry

    A Higher National Diploma student of Business Administration, Federal Polytechnic Auchi, Stephen Ohimai Asekhame, yesterday, appealed to Nigerian government to assist him in getting back to his feet following limb amputation from gunshot wounds sustained during the #EndSARS protest.

    He made the appeal at the resumption of hearing of the Edo State Judicial Panel of Inquiry, in Benin City.

    Ohimia said life has become so difficult for him since he lose one of his legs to a bullet allegedly shot by the Nigerian Army during the recent #EndSARS protest in Auchi.

    Narrating his ordeal, the victim said the incident happened at Jattu junction in Auchi, the administrative headquarter of Etsako West Local Government Area of Edo State, while youths from the area trooped out to rally behind Nigerians across the country demanding an end to police brutality and extrajudicial killings.

    “Others have been organising their protest, and Auchi did theirs on October 19. I wasn’t an organiser of the protest. The reason I came out of the protest was because we the youths are tired of police brutality.

    ” We held placards with inscriptions such as #EndSARS and end police brutality.

    “What happened was that on the 19th of October, Auchi
    decided to do their protest, and I went for the protest which held at Jattu junction. It was a peaceful protest but unfortunately at 2pm, men of the Nigerian Army drove in, shot repeatedly, and one of the gun bullets hit my leg where I was hiding.

    “I came to this panel to appeal to the government do all it can to get me a better life. I want the government to come my to my aid and help me get back to my feet, and get justice,” he said.

  • SARs operatives stole, sold my car, land; tortured me for 47 days, victim tells Lagos judicial panel

    SARs operatives stole, sold my car, land; tortured me for 47 days, victim tells Lagos judicial panel

    The Judicial Panel of Enquiry and Restitution for Victims of SARS related abuses in Lagos, got underway Tuesday with one of the petitioners recounting his Police brutality ordeal.

    Okolieagu Obunike, a father of five, told the panel that in 2012, Federal Special Anti-Robbery Squad (FSARS) operatives detained and tortured him for 47 days at their Ikeja office, without trial.

    Obunike alleged that the operatives also stole and sold his car, a Volkswagen bus, land, bags of cement, inverter and carted away all the possessions in his house.

    He testified as the first petitioner since the Governor Babajide Sanwo-Olu set up the nine-member panel on October 15, following weeks of near nationwide #EndSARS protests.

    SARS – the Special Anti-Robbery Squad – was dissolved by the Inspector-General of Police following protests over the atrocious conduct of the unit.

    Three other petitioners were scheduled for hearing yesterday. They are: a paraplegic on wheelchair, Mr Ndukwe Ekekwe; Olukoya Ogungbeje: and Mr Basil Chetal Ejiagwa.

    But only Obunike’s testified in person. Ogungbeje, a lawyer, and Ejiagwa were absent but represented by their counsel.

    They prayed the court to adopt their petitions as their testimony.

    The court granted their applications.

    The testimony of Ekekwe, whose spine was broken after allegedly being thrown from a two-storey building, was adjourned to give the Commissioner of Police in Lagos time to appear and respond to the allegations.

    Panel chair, Judge emeritus Doris Okuwobi, adjourned till 10am on October 30.

    The panel was scheduled to begin full sitting on Monday, but could not do so because three of its members Rinu Oduala, Temitope Majekodunmi and Lucas Koyejo had yet to be sworn in.

    Upon their arrival, Oduala and Majekodunmi, both youth representatives nominated by an online poll took their oaths alongside Koyejo, the Zonal Coordinator (South-West Zone) – National Human Rights Commission (NHRC).

    Obunike told the panel that he was arrested after tendering his resignation as manager of a firm, following a false complaint of theft by his boss.

    He said he was first taken to Ojo Police Station before being transferred to FSARS office at Ikeja.

    There, he was beaten, hung on a pole and paraded as a thief in a market after he refused to confess to a bogus theft charge, a day after his arrest.

    “They started beating me, paraded me before Alaba Market. The beating was too much. They broke my head. Then they took me back to the station and called my boss. I spent 47 days with SARS,” Obunike said.

    He identified the policemen responsible as Inspector Sunday alias” Baba Ijapa” and ASP (Assistant Superintended) Haruna.

    He said: “My family didn’t know where I was. When my mother and wife finally came. They beat them up in my presence. They took over my house, sold my car, my inverter, phones and seized my land documents.”

    The petitioner said he eventually got judgment against the Police on February 26, 2016 at the Federal High Court in Lagos.

    Justice Ibrahim Buba ordered the Police to him N10million as exemplary damages, but the Police refused to pay.

    He added: “No compensation has been made till date. That’s why I came forward to the panel. My properties were not given back to me. The only one I have got back is the landed property document in 2017. Justice (Mobolanle) Okikiolu-Ighile ordered the release of my documents.”

    When asked what he wanted of the panel, Obunike said: “”I want the panel to compel the police to do what the court has said. I am tired of suffering…feeding,school fees is a problem.”

    Justice Okuwobi promised that the panel would make its findings on Obunike’s allegations public within seven working days.

    Afterwards, Lagos State Attorney-General and Commissioner for Justice Moyosore Onigbanjo SAN, pledged that the government would not interfere in the panel’s work, adding that the state is “determined to get to the bottom of this matter and will leave no stone unturned to ensure justice is done on both sides.”

    He added: “Lagos would ensure the the panel’s independence. There will be no interference from the Executive. Anybody who has been abused should come forward.”

    Nigerian Bar Association (NBA) President Olumide Akpata also pledged the association’s cooperation with the panel. Akpata pledged to send in an observer for every day of the sitting.

    Apart from Justice Okuwobi (Rtd), Oduala and Temitope other members of the panel are Senior Advocate of Nigeria (SAN) Ebun-Olu Adegboruwa, Director, Lagos State Directorate of Citizen’s Rights, Mrs Oluwatoyin Odusanya; a representative of the civil society groups Ms Patience Udoh, and a human rights activist, Mr Segun Awosanya (Segalink).

    The panel will sit from 10am to 4pm for six months. The designated sitting days are Tuesday, Friday and Saturday at the Lagos Court of Arbitration, No 1A, Remi Oluwode Street, Lekki Phase 1, Lagos.

    The panellists are tasked with listening to the submissions of survivors, interrogating the accused persons, determining the veracity of all claims, recommending punishments for the guilty and appropriate compensation for the victims.

  • #EndSARS: Lagos, Ogun, Ekiti, Delta, Edo, Abia, Plateau inaugurate panels on SARS abuses

    #EndSARS: Lagos, Ogun, Ekiti, Delta, Edo, Abia, Plateau inaugurate panels on SARS abuses

    Lagos, Ogun, Ekiti, Abia, Delta, Edo and Plateau states on Monday inaugurated panels to probe cases of human rights abuses against the disbanded Special Anti-Robbery Squad (SARS).

    Lagos Governor Babajide Sanwo-Olu, while inaugurating the panel, appealed to youths protesting police brutality to vacate Lagos roads and embrace dialogue for resolution of the issues.

    He said the government has shown sincerity and willingness to address all concerns raised.

    Sanwo-Olu’s appeal came on the heel of violent dimension assumed by the #EndSARS protests in some parts of the state.

    According to Sanwo-Olu, the Lagos State government has also established a compensation fund for the victims of police brutality.

    He said: “We have shown an unprecedented commitment to the complete overhaul of the Nigeria Police. The inauguration of this Judicial Panel of Inquiry is only the first step in a long line of reformative actions that will lead to a thorough revamp and reorientation of the Nigeria Police. I believe that some of the actions we have taken should, to a large extent, show our sincerity and willingness to address all your concerns.

    “Let me reiterate that I am on the side of the young people out there. I understand your pain and I know your concerns are genuine and legitimate. While we are able to immediately acquiesce to some of your demands, some others will require time. We ask you to bear with us as we dutifully work on your demands.

    “I will, therefore, like to renew my appeal to you to suspend the protests and create an atmosphere for the resolution of all pending demands. I encourage everyone brutalised by the disbanded SARS, including the families of those who died, to present their case before this tribunal.”

    Sanwo-Olu said he believed the task of reforming the police was achievable, but required the input and cooperation of the youth to accomplish.

    He commended the cohesiveness of the “resilient” young people who stood their ground in the last two weeks. Their tenacity, Sanwo-Olu said, has made the much-desired change in the policing system become inevitable.

    Speaking about the judicial panel, the Governor said he was convinced that its outcome and recommendations would open a new chapter in the police-citizen relationship.

    He promised that the State Government would ensure that all wounds are healed, justice served to victims of abuse, and guilty police officers prosecuted.

    At the time of the swearing-in of the panel members, the representatives of the youth in the panel had not been nominated by the protesters.

    The government, last Friday, reached out to the protesters to forward the name of their nominees into the judicial panel. The protesters, however, pleaded for more time to send the names of their nominees, four days after the government’s request.

    Ogun State Governor Dapo Abiodun, who also inaugurated the Judiciary Panel of Investigation on SARS atrocities in his office at Oke-Mosan, Abeokuta, called on members to make fairness, firmness, dedication and objectivity their watchwords.

    Abiodun enjoined the panel to shun all acts which could impact negatively on their assignment, urging stakeholders in the security, peace and conflict resolution processes as well as the mass media to give the Panel the needed support to succeed.

    “Needless to remind you all of the import of your assignment to the continued peace and security of our dear State, in particular, and our great Nation, in general. The people of our dear State await the outcome of your assignment. Indeed, I expect you to commence your assignment immediately and hold an inaugural meeting today.

    “It is imperative that you make fairness, firmness, dedication and objectivity your watchword. You must shun all acts which could impact negatively on your duty. In the same vein, I enjoin all stakeholders in the security; peace and conflict resolution process; the mass media; and, in fact, all the people of our dear State to give this Judicial Panel of Investigation all the necessary support and cooperation needed for them to succeed.

    “Though this panel has six months to conclude this assignment, we will not wait for six months before we begin to implement. They will be taking the reports in phases so we can take immediate action,” he said.

    According to the governor, the terms of reference for the Judicial Panel of Investigation are to receive and investigate complaints of police brutality, human right violation or related extrajudicial killings in the state; evaluation of the evidence presented or other surrounding circumstances and draw a conclusion as to “the validity of the complaints and recommend compensation and other remedial measures more appropriate so that cheques can be issued; determine the officers responsible in the abuse of victims and recommend their prosecution, make recommendations to the Ogun State government on how to ensure that Security agencies no longer abuse the rights of our citizens.”

    Aside the Judicial Panel of Investigation on Human Rights Abuses in the state, a Special Security and Human Rights Committee was also set up under the chairmanship of the governor while the Human Rights Complaint Office with an Ombudsman and two other members were also set up.

    The Chairman of the Panel, Retired Justice Solomon Olugbemi, thanked the governor for the confidence reposed in him and his team, pledging that the panel would ensure that justice was served to everyone irrespective of social or political standing in the society.

    Ekiti State Governor Dr Kayode Fayemi also released the names and terms of reference of the panel to probe abuses by SARS.

    Members of the Panel are Justice Cornelius Akintayo (Chairman), Mr. Dipo Ayeni, A RETIRED Commissioner of Police, Mrs. Yetunde Kolawole, State Counsel- (Representing the Honourable Attorney-General & Commissioner for Justice), Mrs. Kikelomo Owolabi, Chairperson, Nigerian Bar Association, Ikere-Ekiti Branch, Mr. Rotimi Ojomoyela, Chair, Nigerian Union of Journalists, Ekiti State Branch, Mr. Jamiu Abiodun Adigun, Representative, National Human Rights Commission, Mr. Adeyinka Opaleke, Representative, Legal Aid Council of Nigeria, Ms. Caroline Fakinlede, Ekiti State Youths Representative, Mr. Abiola Johnson-Ogunleye- Ekiti State Students Representative and Mr. Akin Rotimi, a researcher on Police Reforms.

    The panel will receive and investigate complaints of Police brutality or related extra-judicial killings, among others.

    In Jos, the Plateau State capital, Governor Simon Bako Lalong inaugurated an 8-member Judicial Commission of Inquiry.

    Lalong, while inaugurating the commission of inquiry, at the Government House, urged the members to investigate complaints from aggrieved individuals, victims and groups, who might have been brutalised, killed and humiliated by the SARS.

    The governor, in his terms of reference to the Justice Philomena Lot-led panel, urged the panel to also evaluate evidence and draw conclusions on the validity of complaints as well as recommend Compensation and other remedial measures.

    Lalong said the commission has six months to conclude its assignment and submit its report to him.

    His Edo State counterpart, Godwin Obaseki, urged the state’s panel to within ninety days to look into circumstances surrounding the protests in the Southsouth state.

    Secretary to the Edo State Government (SSG) Osarodion Ogie, on Monday in a statement, listed members of the panel as Justice Ada Ehigiamusoe (Chairperson); Bishop Feb Idahosa, representing clerics; Francis Osayi, the representative of Academic Staff Union of Universities (ASUU); Osahon Obasuyi, representing the National Youth Council (NYC); Prest Aigbokhian (civil society); Mrs. Uloaku Uzamere, the National Council for Women Societies (NCWS): Pius Efofan, the representative of National Association of Nigerian Students (NANS); Pius Okpere and Kola Edokpayi (#EndSARS Movement); Mrs. Felicia Monyei (Ministry of Justice); unnamed representative of security forces; and Mrs. Joyce Ugbodaga, Secretary to the panel.

    The terms of reference of the panel are: “To receive complaints and petitions from the general public, particularly victims or relatives of victims of police brutality and extra-judicial killings, and to recommend measures, including compensation and restitution, investigation and prosecution, as the circumstances warrant.

    “To advise on compensation or restitution to the victims, or – where the victims have been killed – to the family of the victims, based on a condition which shall be clearly laid out by the panel.

    “To ensure that compensation is paid within 14 days of the decision to compensate.

    “To recommend and direct the Attorney-General to immediately prosecute all persons responsible for the various crimes committed.

    “To recommend measures to forestall reoccurrences in the future and to make any other recommendation to the government, in furtherance of the mandate of panel.”

    Abia State Governor Dr Okezie Ikpeazu also approved the inauguration of a Judicial Panel of Inquiry to investigate allegations of extra-judicial killings and brutality by security agents in the state.

    The committee, according to the statement by Information Commissioner John Okiyi-Kalu, would be inaugurated on Friday at the Government House, Umuahia.

    In Delta, the government said plans were underway to set up a Special Victims’ Support Fund to pay monetary compensation to victims of police brutality or related extra-judicial killings in the state.

    Governor Ifeanyi Okowa spoke yesterday in Asaba while inaugurating an eight-member Judicial Panel of Enquiry into police brutality and other human rights abuses in the state.

    He said that the constitution of the panel was in line with the directive of the National Economic Council (NEC) headed by Vice President Yemi Osinbajo, and charged the body to bring justice to victims.